Here is something that surprises almost everyone who owes back taxes: the letter demanding payment might not come from a government office at all. It might come from a private company in Iowa, Pennsylvania, or Texas. So does the IRS use collection agencies? Yes, it absolutely does — and Congress actually ordered the agency to do it. Since 2017, private debt collectors have worked millions of overdue federal tax accounts under contract with the Treasury Department, and they have pulled in more than a billion dollars in payments.
That reality creates real confusion and real risk. Scammers know most people assume the IRS never uses outside collectors, so they exploit that gap with threatening phone calls. Meanwhile, taxpayers who receive legitimate letters often panic, ignore them, or hand over money to the wrong party. In this guide, you will learn exactly which companies hold IRS contracts, how an account gets assigned to one, what these collectors can and cannot legally do, how to verify a call is real, your rights under federal law, payment options that stay under your control, and how to get your account pulled back to the IRS if you qualify. By the end, you will know precisely how to respond to any collection contact about federal taxes.
The Short Answer: Private Debt Collectors Work Federal Tax Accounts
Yes, the IRS uses private collection agencies to pursue certain overdue tax debts, but only a small number of approved contractors handle these accounts, and they operate under strict federal rules that limit what they can say and do. This is not a secret arrangement or a policy the IRS invented on its own. Congress passed a law in December 2015 — the Fixing America’s Surface Transportation Act, usually called the FAST Act — that required the Treasury Secretary to hand off specific categories of inactive tax receivables to private firms. The program launched in April 2017 and has continued ever since.
Here is the key distinction that trips people up. These private collection agencies, or PCAs, do not replace the IRS. They do not have badges, they cannot seize property, and they cannot file liens. They function more like polite but persistent messengers who remind you about a balance, discuss payment options, and route your money straight to the U.S. Treasury. The IRS still owns the debt from start to finish. The contractor simply works the account on the government’s behalf and earns a commission on what it recovers.
It also helps to understand what these agencies are not. They are not the same as the debt buyers who purchase defaulted credit card accounts for pennies on the dollar. Your tax debt never gets sold. It never transfers ownership. The private firm has no financial claim against you at all, which means it cannot report the debt to credit bureaus, sue you, or add its own fees on top of what you already owe.
One more foundational point: this program only touches a slice of the overall collection picture. The IRS Collection function still handles the vast majority of enforcement directly through its own revenue officers, automated notices, levies, and liens. Private collectors get the leftovers — accounts that have gone quiet, often for years, because the IRS lacked the staff or resources to pursue them.
Why Congress Pushed the IRS Toward Outside Collectors
Understanding the history helps explain why this program exists despite years of criticism. The federal government has actually tried private tax collection three separate times, and each attempt sparked debate about cost, effectiveness, and taxpayer treatment.
Three Rounds of Private Tax Collection
The first experiment ran as a pilot in 1996 and 1997. It lasted about a year and lost money — the IRS spent more running the program than the contractors brought in. The second attempt began in 2006 under a different statute and ended in March 2009, when the IRS commissioner concluded that agency employees collected the same debts more efficiently and at lower cost. The third and current round started with the FAST Act, which made the program mandatory rather than optional. That distinction matters enormously, because the IRS cannot simply decide to shut it down.
The reasoning behind the 2015 law came down to two numbers. First, the IRS faced a mountain of unpaid taxes — the gross accounts receivable balance has hovered well above $100 billion for years. Second, budget cuts had shrunk the IRS workforce dramatically, and the agency was shelving huge numbers of collection cases simply because nobody had time to work them. Lawmakers looked at those inactive accounts and saw money sitting on the table.
The Arguments on Both Sides
Supporters and critics both raise fair points, and knowing them helps you understand the environment you are dealing with:
- Supporters say the program recovers money the government would otherwise write off, costs nothing up front since contractors earn a commission, and lets IRS employees focus on complex or high-dollar cases.
- Critics say the commission structure creates pressure on collectors, the program has historically targeted low-income taxpayers who cannot realistically pay, and net revenue after administrative costs has run thin or negative in past rounds.
- The National Taxpayer Advocate has repeatedly flagged concerns, particularly about accounts belonging to people with incomes below the federal poverty line, and pushed for exclusions that Congress later adopted.
- The Treasury Inspector General for Tax Administration (TIGTA) audits the program regularly and publishes reports on compliance, revenue, and taxpayer complaints.
Congress responded to some criticism in the Taxpayer First Act of 2019. That law barred the IRS from assigning accounts of taxpayers whose adjusted gross income falls at or below 200 percent of the federal poverty level, and it excluded accounts where substantially all the income comes from Social Security disability or Supplemental Security Income. It also stretched the maximum installment agreement a private collector can set up from five years to seven.
Which Companies Hold IRS Collection Contracts
The IRS does not open this work to just any collection agency. It awards contracts through a competitive federal procurement process, and only a handful of firms have ever qualified. Over the life of the current program, the roster has included companies such as CBE Group of Cedar Falls, Iowa; Coast Professional of Albion, New York; ConServe (Continental Service Group) of Fairport, New York; Performant Recovery of Livermore, California; and Pioneer Credit Recovery of Horseheads, New York.
The active list changes when contracts expire or get rebid, so the smartest move is always to check the current roster on IRS.gov rather than trusting a name you read somewhere. The IRS maintains a page dedicated to the private debt collection program that lists every authorized agency along with its mailing address and phone number.
How to Verify an Agency Is Legitimate
Because scammers impersonate these companies constantly, verification should become your automatic first step. Follow this sequence:
- Look for IRS Notice CP40 in your mail. The IRS always sends this letter before any private collector contacts you. It names the specific agency assigned to your account.
- Confirm the agency also mailed you its own initial letter. Legitimate collectors send a written notice after the CP40 arrives.
- Match the 10-digit Taxpayer Authentication Number. The CP40 contains a unique number split into two halves — the collector provides one half, you provide the other. If the caller cannot produce the correct half, hang up.
- Cross-check the company name against the current list on IRS.gov.
- Call the agency back at the number printed on your IRS letter, not the number the caller gives you.
Consider a practical scenario. Maria owed about $6,800 from a tax year six years back and had heard nothing for a long stretch. One Tuesday she got a letter from the IRS labeled CP40 saying her account had gone to ConServe. Two weeks later, a letter from ConServe arrived with the same account details. When a representative finally called, she asked for the authentication number, matched it against her CP40, and only then talked about payment. That five-minute verification protected her from any chance of a scam and gave her confidence the conversation was real.
Which Tax Debts Get Assigned and Which Never Do
Not every unpaid balance ends up with a private collector. The IRS applies a filter, and knowing where you fall tells you a lot about what to expect. The law defines assignable accounts as “inactive tax receivables,” which generally means one of three situations applies.
First, the IRS removed the account from its active inventory because of a lack of resources or an inability to locate you. Second, more than a third of the applicable limitations period has passed and no IRS employee has been assigned to collect it. Third, an account has sat in the queue for over a year without any employee working it. In plain terms, these are old, quiet debts that fell through the cracks.
Accounts the IRS Cannot Assign
Federal law carves out a long list of protected categories. Your account will not go to a private collector if any of these apply:
| Excluded Category | Why It Is Protected |
|---|---|
| Deceased taxpayers | Estate handling requires IRS involvement |
| Taxpayers under age 18 | Minors receive special protection |
| Designated combat zone participants | Active military service protections apply |
| Confirmed identity theft victims | Debt validity is in question |
| Accounts under examination, litigation, criminal investigation, or levy | Already active with the IRS |
| Pending or active installment agreements | Taxpayer is already resolving the debt |
| Pending or active offers in compromise | Settlement process in motion |
| Accounts in innocent spouse relief cases | Liability determination pending |
| Taxpayers in federally declared disaster areas requesting relief | Hardship relief applies |
| Income at or below 200% of the federal poverty level | Added by the Taxpayer First Act of 2019 |
| Income substantially from SSDI or SSI | Added by the Taxpayer First Act of 2019 |
| Accounts with an active Taxpayer Advocate Service case | Independent review underway |
| Currently not collectible status due to hardship | Inability to pay already documented |
| Accounts with pending or active appeals | Dispute rights being exercised |
To put the scale in perspective, the IRS has assigned millions of accounts to private collectors since 2017, and TIGTA reports have tracked cumulative payments passing the $1 billion mark. Average assigned balances tend to run in the several-thousand-dollar range, and a large share of assigned accounts involve tax years that are five or more years old. That profile confirms the design: old, small-to-midsize individual balances that the IRS had already set aside.
How the Process Works From First Letter to Final Payment
The sequence follows a predictable pattern, and every step includes a written record. If a step is missing, treat that as a red flag.
Step One: The IRS Notifies You First
Before anything else happens, the IRS mails you Notice CP40 (or Letter LT16 in some situations) telling you it has transferred your account to a specific private collection agency. This letter includes the agency’s name, its contact information, and the first half of your Taxpayer Authentication Number. The IRS also sends Publication 4518, which explains the program and your rights in plain language.
Step Two: The Agency Sends Its Own Letter
The assigned agency then mails its own initial contact letter confirming the transfer and repeating the balance owed. Only after both letters go out will the agency attempt to reach you by phone. This double-notification requirement exists specifically so you are never blindsided by an unexpected call.
Step Three: Phone Contact and Authentication
When a representative calls, both sides authenticate. The rep gives one portion of the authentication number, and you give the other. The rep will also confirm identifying details. These calls follow federal rules on timing — collectors may not call before 8 a.m. or after 9 p.m. in your local time zone, and they must stop calling if you tell them in writing to stop.
Step Four: Discussing Payment
The collector will ask you to pay in full. If you cannot, the representative can set up an installment agreement lasting up to seven years, provided the plan pays the balance off within that window and before the collection statute expires. If you need something more complex — a settlement, hardship status, or penalty relief — the agency must send your account back to the IRS.
Step Five: Payment Goes to the Treasury, Never the Agency
This is the single most important rule in the entire program. You never send money to the collection agency. Every legitimate payment goes to the United States Treasury. You can pay online at IRS.gov/payments, through IRS Direct Pay, using the Electronic Federal Tax Payment System (EFTPS), by debit or credit card through an approved processor, or by check made payable to “United States Treasury” and mailed to the IRS address on your notice. If anyone asks you to make a check out to a company name, wire funds, buy gift cards, or send cryptocurrency, you are talking to a criminal.
What Private Collectors Can and Cannot Do
Private collection agencies operate under a much tighter leash than IRS employees. Knowing the boundaries protects you from intimidation, whether it comes from an overzealous rep or an outright scammer.
| Action | Private Collection Agency | IRS |
|---|---|---|
| Send letters about your balance | Yes | Yes |
| Call you about payment | Yes, within legal hours | Yes |
| Set up an installment agreement | Yes, up to 7 years | Yes, longer terms possible |
| Accept your payment directly | No | Payments go to Treasury |
| File a federal tax lien | No | Yes |
| Issue a levy or garnish wages | No | Yes |
| Seize property or bank accounts | No | Yes |
| Approve an offer in compromise | No | Yes |
| Grant currently not collectible status | No | Yes |
| Abate or reduce penalties | No | Yes |
| Threaten arrest or jail | Never legal | Never legal for civil debt |
| Demand gift cards or wire transfers | Never legal | Never legal |
| Add extra collection fees to your balance | No | Statutory penalties and interest only |
Private collectors must follow the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act, which is the same law that governs credit card and medical debt collectors. That means no harassment, no profane language, no calls at unreasonable hours, no false statements about the amount you owe, and no threats of action they cannot legally take. They also must follow IRS-specific contract rules layered on top of the FDCPA.
Here is a real-world illustration of the limits. Suppose a taxpayer named Dev owes $9,200 and truly cannot pay anything because he lost his job. The private collector cannot place him in currently not collectible status — it simply lacks that authority. What the collector must do is return the account to the IRS so an IRS employee can evaluate his financial situation. Dev can request that return at any time, and the agency has to honor it.
Spotting Scam Calls That Pretend to Be IRS Collectors
The private collection program handed impersonation scammers a convenient cover story. Before 2017, you could safely assume any caller claiming to collect IRS debt was fake. Now the answer requires a little more care — but the tell-tale signs remain easy to spot once you know them.
Every year, thousands of people report tax-related phone scams, and victims have collectively lost tens of millions of dollars since these schemes took off. The scripts have grown more sophisticated, sometimes spoofing caller ID to display a Washington, D.C. area code or a real agency’s phone number. Still, scammers give themselves away because they need money fast and cannot follow the actual process.
Warning Signs of a Fake Collection Call
- The caller contacts you out of the blue with no IRS letter arriving first.
- They demand immediate payment and refuse to let you verify anything.
- They ask for gift cards, prepaid debit cards, wire transfers, cryptocurrency, or payment apps.
- They tell you to make a check payable to anything other than “United States Treasury.”
- They threaten arrest, deportation, license revocation, or police at your door.
- They ask for your full Social Security number, bank login, or card number over the phone.
- They refuse to give you a name, agency, and callback number you can verify independently.
- They cannot provide the correct half of your Taxpayer Authentication Number.
- They pressure you to stay on the line and not hang up or consult anyone.
What to Do If You Suspect a Scam
Hang up first. Do not argue, do not confirm any personal details, and do not call back the number they gave you. Then check your actual tax status by creating or logging into your online account at IRS.gov, where you can view your balance for each tax year. If you owe nothing, the call was fake. Report the incident to TIGTA through its website or at 800-366-4484, and file a complaint with the Federal Trade Commission at ReportFraud.ftc.gov. If the caller impersonated a specific private agency, you can also alert that agency and the IRS.
Picture a common version of this scam. Someone calls a retiree named Frank, says his “case number” has been referred for immediate enforcement, and warns that a warrant will issue within the hour unless he buys $3,000 in store gift cards and reads the codes aloud. Every element of that call violates the rules — no prior letter, a threat of arrest, and an impossible payment method. Frank hangs up, logs into IRS.gov, sees a zero balance, and reports the call. Total cost to him: nothing.
Your Rights and How to Get Your Account Back With the IRS
You keep every taxpayer right when a private collector works your account. Nothing in the program strips away protections. In fact, the IRS explicitly reminds assigned taxpayers of the Taxpayer Bill of Rights, which includes the right to quality service, the right to pay no more than the correct amount, the right to challenge the IRS’s position, the right to appeal, the right to privacy, and the right to a fair and just tax system.
Asking the Agency to Stop Contacting You
You can tell a private collection agency in writing to stop contacting you, exactly as you could with any debt collector under the FDCPA. Send your request in writing, keep a copy, and use certified mail if you want proof of delivery. Keep in mind that stopping contact does not erase the debt, and the IRS can still pursue collection through its own channels, including liens and levies.
Requesting Return of Your Account to the IRS
You also have the right to ask that your account go back to the IRS. The agency must return an account when you request it, and it must return accounts in several other situations too:
- You request the return in writing or by phone.
- You dispute the liability or claim identity theft.
- You need an offer in compromise, currently not collectible status, or penalty abatement.
- You are in bankruptcy, a combat zone, or a federally declared disaster area seeking relief.
- You file an appeal or open a Taxpayer Advocate Service case.
- Your financial circumstances mean no realistic payment arrangement fits within the allowed terms.
Free Help Is Available
You do not have to face this alone, and you do not have to pay a large fee to a tax resolution firm. Several free or low-cost resources exist:
- Taxpayer Advocate Service (TAS) — an independent organization inside the IRS that helps when you face hardship or the normal channels are not working. Reach it at 877-777-4778.
- Low Income Taxpayer Clinics (LITCs) — offer free or nominal-cost representation for people under certain income limits, including help with collection disputes.
- IRS online account — lets you check balances, payment history, and notices without calling anyone.
- IRS Publication 594 — the official guide to the collection process.
- IRS Publication 4518 — explains the private debt collection program specifically.
- Enrolled agents, CPAs, and tax attorneys — licensed professionals who can represent you with a signed Form 2848 Power of Attorney.
Smart Ways to Handle a Private Collection Notice
If a CP40 lands in your mailbox, your response over the next few weeks shapes the outcome. Here is how to handle it well and avoid the mistakes that cost people money and stress.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
The biggest error is ignoring the letter. The debt does not disappear because you tossed the envelope. Interest keeps compounding daily, failure-to-pay penalties keep accruing, and the IRS retains full enforcement power in the background, including the ability to seize refunds or issue levies later. A second common mistake is assuming the letter must be a scam because “the IRS never uses collection agencies.” That belief was true before 2017 and is outdated now.
Another frequent misstep involves overpaying for help. Some taxpayers panic and hire an expensive resolution company that promises to settle debts for pennies. Many of those promises fall apart, because settlement approval depends on your actual finances, not on marketing claims. Finally, some people verify nothing and hand over card numbers on a first call. Never do that.
A Better Sequence
- Confirm the debt independently by logging into your IRS online account or ordering an account transcript for the years in question.
- Verify the collection agency against the current list on IRS.gov and match the authentication number.
- Decide whether you can pay in full, need a payment plan, or genuinely cannot pay anything right now.
- If a plan works, set one up — either with the collector or directly through the IRS Online Payment Agreement tool.
- If you need hardship relief, a settlement, or penalty abatement, ask for the account to return to the IRS.
- Keep every letter, note every call with date and name, and save all payment confirmations.
- File all outstanding returns, because the IRS will not approve most arrangements until you are current on filings.
Consider Your Alternatives
Working with the private collector is not your only route. You can bypass the agency entirely and deal with the IRS. Compare the options:
| Option | Best For | Where to Arrange It |
|---|---|---|
| Pay in full | Stops all penalties and interest immediately | IRS Direct Pay or EFTPS |
| Short-term payment plan (up to 180 days) | Balances you can clear quickly | IRS Online Payment Agreement |
| Long-term installment agreement | Steady income, balance under $50,000 | IRS online tool or Form 9465 |
| PCA installment agreement (up to 7 years) | Assigned accounts with manageable balances | The assigned collection agency |
| Offer in compromise | Cannot pay full amount within statute | IRS only, Form 656 |
| Currently not collectible | Severe financial hardship | IRS only, financial disclosure required |
| Penalty abatement | First-time offense or reasonable cause | IRS only |
Where the Private Collection Program Is Headed
The program continues to evolve, and a few trends matter for anyone with an old tax balance. First, contracts rotate. The IRS periodically rebids the work, which means the list of active agencies changes every few years. Always check the current roster rather than relying on memory.
Second, funding shifts inside the IRS influence how many accounts get assigned. When the agency hires more collection staff, fewer cases fall into the “inactive” bucket that qualifies for outsourcing. When budgets tighten, the opposite happens. Watch for that push and pull to keep affecting assignment volumes.
Third, oversight keeps increasing. TIGTA and the National Taxpayer Advocate publish regular reviews examining revenue, costs, and taxpayer treatment. Those reports have already driven meaningful changes, most notably the low-income and disability exclusions added in 2019. More refinements to eligibility rules would not be surprising.
Finally, expect more digital contact and more sophisticated scams running alongside the legitimate program. As the IRS expands online accounts and digital notice delivery, verifying a debt gets easier for honest taxpayers — and impersonators adapt by mimicking those channels through fake emails and texts. Remember the constants: the IRS does not initiate contact by email, text, or social media to demand payment, and neither do its contractors. Written notice comes first, always.
Repeal proposals also surface in Congress from time to time, usually attached to broader taxpayer rights bills. None has succeeded so far, so the practical takeaway stands: plan on the program continuing, and plan on knowing how to verify any contact you receive.
Key Takeaways and Next Steps
To recap the essentials: the IRS does use private collection agencies, but only a small number of contracted firms handle assigned accounts, and only for older, inactive debts that meet specific criteria. The IRS always mails Notice CP40 before any private collector reaches out, the agency then sends its own letter, and the two of you exchange halves of a unique authentication number before discussing anything. These collectors can request payment and set up installment agreements up to seven years, but they cannot levy, lien, seize, arrest, settle, or accept money directly. Every payment goes to the United States Treasury.
That knowledge turns a stressful letter into a manageable task. Verify first, confirm your balance through your own IRS online account, choose the payment path that fits your finances, and remember you can always request that your account return to the IRS if you need hardship relief or a settlement. Free help exists through the Taxpayer Advocate Service and Low Income Taxpayer Clinics if the process feels overwhelming. Tax debt has a way of feeling permanent, but it rarely is — with the right information and a steady plan, most people work through it, protect their rights, and put the balance behind them for good.